The Kalam Cosmological Argument
The Kalam Cosmological Argument (KCA) is a philosophical argument for the existence of God, which asserts that the universe has a cause for its beginning. It has its roots in medieval Islamic philosophy and has been extensively developed in contemporary times by Christian philosopher William Lane Craig. The argument is structured as follows:
Premises and Conclusion
- Premise 1: Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
- Premise 2: The universe began to exist.
- Conclusion: Therefore, the universe has a cause.
Elaboration on the Premises
Premise 1: Everything that begins to exist has a cause
- Intuitive Support: This premise is based on the metaphysical principle that something cannot come from nothing. Our everyday experience and scientific understanding support the idea that things that begin to exist have causes.
- Philosophical Defense: Philosophers argue that denying this premise leads to absurdities, such as things popping into existence without any reason or cause.
Premise 2: The universe began to exist
- Philosophical Arguments: There are several philosophical arguments supporting the idea that the universe had a beginning:
- Impossibility of an Actual Infinite: The concept of an actual infinite number of past events is argued to be impossible. For example, if the past were infinite, it would lead to paradoxes such as Hilbert’s Hotel, which illustrate the contradictions in actual infinities.
- Temporal Sequence of Events: If the universe had no beginning, it would imply an infinite sequence of past events, which is argued to be metaphysically impossible.
Scientific Evidence:
- Big Bang Cosmology: The Big Bang theory suggests that the universe expanded from a singularity approximately 13.8 billion years ago, implying a beginning.
- Second Law of Thermodynamics: This law states that the amount of usable energy in a closed system tends to decrease over time. If the universe were eternal, it would have reached a state of heat death by now.
Conclusion: Therefore, the universe has a cause
Given the two premises, it logically follows that the universe has a cause. Proponents of the KCA argue that this cause must be timeless, spaceless, immaterial, and powerful, which they identify with God.
Attributes of the Cause
To further support that the cause is God, proponents argue that:
- Timeless and Spaceless: Since time and space began with the universe, the cause must exist outside of time and space.
- Immaterial: The cause cannot be material because material objects exist within space and time.
- Powerful: The cause must have immense power to bring the universe into existence.
- Personal: The cause must be personal to decide to create the universe, as an impersonal cause cannot account for a temporal effect from a timeless state.
Criticisms and Responses
- Challenge to Premise 1: Critics question whether everything that begins to exist must have a cause, especially in quantum mechanics, where certain events appear to occur without deterministic causes.
- Response: Proponents argue that quantum events are not uncaused but are governed by probabilistic laws.
- Challenge to Premise 2: Some argue that the universe could be eternal or cyclic, avoiding a beginning.
- Response: Proponents counter with philosophical arguments against the possibility of an actual infinite and cite contemporary cosmological evidence supporting a beginning.
- Nature of the Cause: Some critics argue that even if the universe has a cause, it does not necessarily follow that the cause is the God of classical theism.
- Response: Proponents argue that the attributes of the cause (timeless, spaceless, immaterial, powerful, and personal) closely align with the concept of God.
Conclusion
The Kalam Cosmological Argument provides a compelling case for the existence of a cause for the universe’s beginning. While it has faced various criticisms, its proponents have developed robust responses, making it one of the most discussed and debated arguments in contemporary philosophy of religion.
Shop tip
Kalam Cosmological Argument on Amazon
