Discerning authentic Marian apparitions
How the Church discerns authentic apparitions from false ones?
The Church has a thorough and careful process for discerning authentic Marian apparitions from false ones, rooted in theological, psychological, and empirical investigation. This process includes several key steps:
- Initial Investigation: Local bishops are the first to investigate reported apparitions. They examine the credibility of the witnesses, the consistency of their testimonies, and any immediate spiritual fruits or miracles associated with the apparitions.
- Criteria of Discernment: The Church evaluates apparitions based on specific criteria, including:
- Conformity to Doctrine: The messages of the apparition must align with Catholic teachings and Scriptures.
- Moral Integrity: The individuals receiving the apparitions must lead lives of integrity and faithfulness to Church teachings.
- Psychological Soundness: The visionaries must be mentally and emotionally stable.
- Spiritual Fruits: The apparition should result in positive spiritual outcomes such as conversions, increased prayer, and deeper devotion.
- Commissions and Committees: If the initial investigation warrants further scrutiny, the bishop may form a commission of theologians, psychologists, and other experts to study the phenomenon more deeply. This commission conducts interviews, reviews documentation, and may visit the apparition site.
- Supernatural Origin: The Church considers whether the apparitions have characteristics that point to a supernatural origin, such as inexplicable healings, fulfilled prophecies, and significant spiritual impact.
- Approval Process: After thorough investigation, the local bishop can make a preliminary declaration. If the apparition is deemed worthy of belief, the case may be referred to the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith for further review and final approval.
- Public Devotion: Approval means that the Church permits public devotion connected to the apparition. However, belief in any particular apparition, even an approved one, is not obligatory for Catholics.
Through this meticulous process, the Church ensures that any approved apparition is authentic and beneficial to the faithful, fostering genuine spiritual growth and devotion.
Case study
Let’s illustrate the investigation process using the example of the Marian apparitions at Lourdes, France, witnessed by Saint Bernadette Soubirous in 1858.
Initial Investigation
- Witness Testimony: In February 1858, 14-year-old Bernadette Soubirous reported seeing a “lady” in a grotto near Lourdes. Over several months, she experienced a total of 18 apparitions. The local parish priest and bishop, initially skeptical, began to take her claims seriously as more people came forward with testimonies and as reports of miraculous healings began to surface.
- Preliminary Examination: The local bishop, Bertrand-Sévère Laurence, instructed priests to interview Bernadette extensively. They assessed her character, sincerity, and the consistency of her story. They also observed her behavior during and after the apparitions.
Criteria of Discernment
- Conformity to Doctrine: The messages Bernadette received were simple and consistent with Catholic teachings, urging prayer, penance, and the construction of a chapel at the site.
- Moral Integrity: Bernadette was known to be a humble, honest, and devout girl from a poor family. Her humility and simplicity lent credibility to her claims.
- Psychological Soundness: Medical and psychological evaluations were conducted to rule out any mental illness or hallucinations. Bernadette was found to be mentally sound and free from any deceit or delusion.
- Spiritual Fruits: Reports of spiritual conversions and miraculous healings began to multiply. People who visited the grotto claimed cures from serious illnesses after drinking or bathing in the spring water that Bernadette had uncovered at the Lady’s direction.
Commissions and Committees
- Formation of a Commission: Bishop Laurence established a canonical commission of inquiry composed of theologians, doctors, and scientists to investigate the apparitions and associated phenomena in depth. They scrutinized all aspects of Bernadette’s claims and the reported miracles.
- Examination of Miracles: The commission rigorously investigated the healings attributed to the grotto’s water, seeking to rule out natural explanations. They interviewed those who were healed and collected medical documentation to verify the authenticity of the miracles.
Supernatural Origin
Evaluation of Supernatural Elements: The commission found no natural explanation for many of the healings and noted the significant spiritual impact on the local and broader Catholic community.
Approval Process
Bishop’s Decision: In 1862, after thorough investigation, Bishop Laurence declared the apparitions at Lourdes to be genuine, affirming that the Virgin Mary had indeed appeared to Bernadette. He approved public devotion and the construction of a sanctuary at the site.
Public Devotion
Vatican Recognition: The Vatican later confirmed the local bishop’s approval, and Lourdes became one of the most important pilgrimage sites in the world. The apparitions were recognized as worthy of belief, leading to widespread veneration of Our Lady of Lourdes.
Spiritual Impact
Enduring Devotion: Since the approval, Lourdes has seen millions of pilgrims each year. The site continues to be associated with numerous reports of miraculous healings and deep spiritual experiences.
This case exemplifies the Church’s diligent process of investigation, ensuring that any approved apparition supports and enhances the faith of the Catholic community.
Shop tip
Marian apparitions on Amazon
